言论自由大讨论

评论 (4)

读者须知：自动翻译由Google翻译提供，虽然可以反映作者大意，但不一定能提供精准的译意。

1. xibaixu 说道：

   一月 24, 2012 9:31 下午

   Since YouTube is inaccessible in China, I uploaded the clip to Sina Video, and it was deleted within hours. I am totally baffled because Yan Xuetong is a very well-known scholar in China, and honestly I don’t see anything ‘sensitive’ in the video that would warrant such sanction.

   登录以回复 Report comment
2. EH 说道：

   一月 25, 2012 12:14 上午

   Interesting stuff Xibai – esp his pts about the numerics/temporal nature of ethics. Is it fair to say for him universal values are emergent properties / empirically-revealed codes of behaviour? Rather than something which can be prescribed? Or have I misunderstood?

   登录以回复 Report comment
   • xibaixu 说道：

     一月 25, 2012 12:51 上午

     EH, you are correct. In his opinion, universal values are just ‘out there’, to be discovered through empirical, scientific research rather than debates.

     登录以回复 Report comment
3. kangsheng 说道：

   一月 27, 2012 5:32 上午

   I’m not sure it’s entirely philosophically coherent, but as one of China’s leading IR intellectuals, it’s interesting to see him lay out some of his moral thinking: he’s argued for a while that if China is really to achieve greatness it “needs a model at home that can inspire people abroad” as well as exercising “moral leadership” in its international environment (see e.g. http://nyti.ms/wu9Z0u). What that actually looks like has sometimes been more elusive, but it would probably need to be a version of universalism “with Chinese characteristics”… He has what sounds like a bit of a shot at describing elements of that here. Will be a big debate for China in the decades ahead…

   登录以回复 Report comment